When clients assume your best work was done by AI – MarTech
Identify traffic-stealing competitors
Find untapped opportunities
Create outperforming content
mt logo
MarTech » Marketing management »
Chat with MarTechBot
Please note that your conversations will be recorded.
AI is changing how clients view creative work. Even the best human efforts are starting to be questioned — not for quality, but for authenticity. I recently saw this firsthand.
Below is recent feedback from a client on some content we created.
“I do have a piece of feedback for them. I’m not sure which AI writing tool they’re using to create these, but they may want to take a second pass… a lot of these pieces of copy are clearly first pass AI generations…”
The problem is that our copywriter didn’t use AI and would be offended by the feedback. He’s an award-winning creative with a big agency background. As you might expect, he’s vehemently opposed to using generative AI.
Where is the feedback coming from? It’s from a company whose marketing department strongly embraces generative AI for content creation. I guess they assume their agency is using it as well.
That will be a significant issue if you are on the agency side. Perhaps it already is, and I’m just now experiencing it. Our copywriter is very talented and has a lot of great experience. As a result, he is not inexpensive.
He warrants the rate he receives, now threatened by clients who will discount the value, assuming a tool is responsible for his output.
As more clients adopt generative AI tools for marketing, questions will arise regarding the outputs and cost of agency services, particularly creative agencies.
In this example, it’s content. However, the same scenario could apply to any creative service: creative concepting, AI image generation, media planning, AI audience segmentation, etc. AI is everywhere.
The reality of AI tools is that they are handy and efficient. As a result, we face the challenge of protecting the craftsmanship of our creative resources while leveraging the tools’ value.
I’ve always believed that good copy or content is an art. But what happens if no one appreciates the art? What will be its value?
Many creatives use AI tools for ideation, content refinement, editing, etc. However, to date, I’ve not seen any evidence that AI-generated or modified outputs perform any better than what humans have created in the past.
Dig deeper: What AI means for the future of agency-brand partnerships
Maybe it’s not a choice of “either-or,” but knowing the advantages and disadvantages of each approach (see below) and when to use them situationally to our advantage.
Dig deeper: Riding the AI tsunami: Harnessing creativity and efficiency in the digital age
After pulling this together, I realized where the client feedback came from in our latest content round. Over the last few months, we have been hand-crafting emails for announcements, follow-up emails to events and other marketing outreach activities.
This most recent round, and what generated the feedback, was a change in our approach. We profiled the personalities of the target audience and found that the most dominant personality type was one that prefers concise, to-the-point, no-nonsense content.
We removed the “emotional depth and empathy” mentioned as a strength of human-generated content. As a result, the content had an “emotional flatness,” making it sound like a machine wrote it.
The blending of machine and man is not going away. The only real question is, will it improve our results?
Dig deeper: The AI-powered marketer’s roadmap to the future of content
Contributing authors are invited to create content for MarTech and are chosen for their expertise and contribution to the search community. Our contributors work under the oversight of the editorial staff and contributions are checked for quality and relevance to our readers. MarTech is owned by Semrush. Contributor was not asked to make any direct or indirect mentions of Semrush. The opinions they express are their own.
Related stories
New on MarTech
About the author
Related topics
Fuel up with free marketing insights.
See terms.
Discover time-saving technologies and actionable tactics that can help you overcome crucial marketing challenges.
Now available: MarTech spring
Online Sept. 17-18, 2025: MarTech fall
Learn actionable search marketing tactics that can help you drive more traffic, leads, and revenue.
Start training now:: SMX Advanced
November 14-15, 2022: SMX Next
March 8-9, 2022: Master Classes
Free 14 day Semrush trial
Get 55+ tools to gain insights and grow your audience.
Build Rankings, Authority, and AI Search Visibility with Hyperlocal PR
Turn Real-Time Data into Smarter Customer Journeys
Google Ads Masterclass: New Rules for Maximizing Conversion Rates
Generative AI for Content Creation: A Marketer’s Guide
Email Marketing Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide
Customer Data Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide
A Practical Guide to Agentic AI for Customer Experience
Meet your new AI-powered marketing assistant!
Fuel up with free marketing insights.
Topics
Our events
About
Follow us
© 2025 MarTech.org is a Trademark of Semrush Inc.
Third Door Media, Inc. is a business-to-business media company. It is the publisher of MarTech and the producer of the MarTech Conference. Third Door Media offers marketing solutions that help vendors connect with an engaged audience of B2C and B2B marketers. The company headquarters is 800 Boylston Street, Suite 2475, Boston, MA USA 02199.
